RSS

Archive for July, 2025

Old Wood or Old Parts?

Friday, July 18th, 2025

Old wood will always be old wood. You can age the crap out of new wood and it will still be new wood. You can roast the new wood and it might approach the tonal qualities of old wood but maybe not. If you can’t afford the vintage guitar you want, you can build one slowly. This 60 husk sold for about a third of what the entire guitar would have cost.

Not everyone can afford to play in the vintage sandbox. I get that. When I started buying vintage guitars, they were a lot less expensive but I had a lot less money. My limit back in the mid 90’s when I started doing this was around $1000. The first vintage guitar I ever bought was a 62 Epiphone Crestwood. It was refinished and had a lot of changed parts and it cost me $600. It sounded great. Within a year or so, I was spending up to $6000 which was enough to score a 1960 ES-345 with PAFs (and a Bigsby). It was all original and there was a lesson in that…it is easier to sell a no issues guitar than it is to sell one with issues like changed parts, repairs or a refinish. By the early 2000’s, prices started taking off and I felt like I was chasing the market up and I was spending as much as $15,000 for guitars. I still wasn’t a dealer-it was just a hobby so when the market tanked in ’08, I only had five or six guitars and I got beat up pretty good but not as badly as many dealers. That lesson stuck with me. It is still easier to sell a no issue guitar than to sell one with issues.

That lesson is of no use at all if you don’t have the budget to buy a no issue vintage guitar that you will want to play. So, given a limited budget, what do you do to protect your investment and still get a guitar you want to play? Do you buy a guitar that’s refinished or repaired? Do you buy one with lots of changed parts? Do you buy a husk and build from there? Lots of good questions but there are lots of good answers.

I have strong opinions on the subject and you can listen to me or dismiss me. They are, after all, opinions. Two factors spring to the forefront…tone and playability. We can add investment potential to that as well. It’s a little like the real estate rule of location, location, location. Just as you can’t easily change the location of the house you buy, you can’t undo many of the issues that keep guitar prices down to affordable levels. You can’t undo a repair. You can’t undo a refinish. You can’t make new wood into old wood except by waiting a very long time. You can change parts though and that is key here.

One solution is to buy an old guitar that is all there but not currently all that valuable. 70’s guitars have not run up in value all that much but a lot of 70’s guitars are crap. 80’s guitars are generally better quality and are often very affordable. So, if you’re willing to wait for your investment to mature over the next twenty years or more, then buy an early 80’s 335 or maybe a 76 Explorer. Or even a BC Rich. A general rule is to buy the best guitar of a given era. But what about getting into vintage cheap without having to take a chance on whether your 70’s or 80’s guitar is going to go up in value? Buy old wood. I’ll say it again…old wood is the location, location, location equivalent.

Husks (body and neck) are not easy to find. If you are lucky enough to find one, it’s the perfect way to “build” your investment guitar. Can’t find a husk? Buy an old guitar with lots of changed parts. That way, you can, over time, replace the repro or incorrect parts with correct ones. Make sure the neck is in good shape. Fixing a backbow or a twist can be expensive and the results aren’t always good. Try to find a guitar that has a properly functioning truss rod that isn’t all the way loose (very common). If the guitar you find is playable and sounds OK with repro or changed parts, then it will only improve as you swap in the correct parts. parts like tuners, tailpieces, bridges and plastic don’t affect tone all that much so maybe start with the electronics. PAFs are crazy expensive right now but there is no substitute (other than early patents which are the same). Plenty of boutique PAFs sound as good as the real thing but if you’re building a vintage guitar, you need vintage parts. Parts should hold their value even through bad times. In 2008, the price of parts was barely affected.

You can get a great deal with a refinished or repaired vintage guitar and it can adequately fill the bill for playability and tone. The problem is the investment angle. Refins and repaired guitars are usually poor investments. Don’t care about the investment value? Buy a well repaired or properly refinished vintage guitar and have fun. When it’s time to sell, don’t expect big profits or an easy sale. But if you bought an old husk and slowly built it out, you will reap the same benefits as you would if you had bought that guitar you couldn’t afford five years ago. Correct parts aren’t the equivalent of original parts but many buyers don’t care as long as the parts are correct. The exception to this is mint or near mint guitars. But if you’re buying a husk or a guitar with lots of changed parts, it’s pretty unlikely that it will be in that kind of condition anyway.

I recently sold a 60 ES-335 husk for $18000. An average condition no issue 1960 is a $60,000 guitar. Buying all of the parts to make it 100% correct will cost you somewhat more than one that is original but you will have the luxury of doing it slowly. I would make it playable right away with inexpensive repro parts and play it while I build it out. When you’re done, you might just have the guitar of your dreams. If you don’t, you’ll be able to sell it without having to make a lot of excuses. I think that beats buying a guitar from the 70’s or 80’s and hoping the market “discovers” how great guitars were in the 70’s and 80’s. The problem is that guitars from the 70’s and 80’s weren’t great. They might be old but they don’t quite fit the somewhat fuzzy description of “vintage”.

If you want to take a chance and buy something from the 70’s or 80’s, these early 80’s Korinas might be the best bet. Explorers and V’s from the 70’s (which weren’t Korina) are probably going to continue appreciating. I’d stay away from 335’s from the 70’s but would consider the ones built from 81 until 85 as a good future collectible.

On the Cusp 59-60

Monday, July 7th, 2025

Well, you certainly can’t tell by looking if this is a late 58, 59 or 60 by looking at the photo. If you play it and you’ve played more than a few, you’ll know it’s either a late 59 (Sept or later) or an early 60 (April or earlier) Only a look at the serial number can tell you because a late 59 and an early 60 are completely identical.

I’ve written this more than a few times but it’s more relevant today than it has ever been. I’ll explain why after I repeat myself for the zillionth time: Guitars, unlike automobiles, didn’t have “model years.” Unless a brand new model was being pitched, Gibson did ads for the “new, improved 1960 ES-335”. They might have pitched the “new Gibson Firebird” which was released late in 1963-nowhere near a new year. The reason there were no model years is simple…Gibson made changes and improvements as needed. No reason to wait until January 1 to implement changes (and there were a lot of changes to the ES guitars over the decades they have been produced. OK, if you are a frequent reader, you knew that. If you aren’t, remember it. It might save you a few thousand dollars.

So, why is it important now? Well, it was important before but now it’s kind of glaring. The value of 1959 ES guitars has moved northward faster than treasure hunters to the Klondike. All of the ES line has increased in value in the past 5 years or so but not all of them have moved at the same rate. The 59 ES-335 went from being a $40,000 guitar in 2018 (stop tail 9/10 condition, all original) to now being a nearly $90,000 guitar. But, while all 1959’s are not created equal, the value of pretty much all 59’s has risen at about the same rate. An early 59 and a late ’59 are rather different guitars in at least one very significant way. The neck profile went from big, round and chunky to a decidedly medium, slightly flatter profile in the Fall of 1959. Lots of folks like the early big neck and lots like the slimmer late ’59 “transitional” neck. We call it transitional but it was around for nearly a year and therein lies my point. A September ’59 ES-335 has a medium neck. But so does an April 1960. And every 335 in between those dates with few exceptions. There are other changes that occurred between ’59 and ’60 but none of them were introduced on January 1. The bonnet knobs of ’59 were changed to reflectors but not until late in the Spring of ’60. The tuners went from single ring Klusons to double ring Klusons but, again, not at the start of the year. What does all this mean? It means that an early to mid ’60 is exactly, exactly the same as a mid to late ’59. No difference at all. Except for the price.

An early ’60 ES-335 will cost you somewhere around $65K (stop tail 9/10 condition, all original). That same guitar, if it has a ’59 serial number, will cost you at least $10,000 more. $10,000 is real money. Buy an early ’60’s SG Special with what’s left over or an early ’70’s 4 bolt Strat. That begs the question about how to date a “cusp” guitar in the late ’50’s to the early ’60’s when they had factory order numbers (FON). You can argue that many early ’60 Gibsons were actually built in 1959 if they have an “S” FON. Actually the “S” means the build was started in 1959 and not necessarily completed. I have a ’60 ES-335 with a ’58 FON. That doesn’t make it a ’58. That makes it a ’60 with a ’58 FON. You can use whatever parameter you want to date your Gibson but most of us dealers use the serial number which tells you when it left the factory. You can call it a ’60 with a ’59 FON. Buyers will know exactly what you mean. It’s a very complete description but it’s going to price your guitar as a ’60. If somebody sells me a 335 that they describe as a ’59 and I get it and the serial number is 1960, I will send it back. Put the FON in your listing in giant letters with flashing neon but if the serial number is 1960, you best mention it in your listing even if the font is minuscule and it’s buried in the text. As long as it’s there. I digress.

It’s worth noting that different buyers of vintage guitars have different reasons for buying them. If you are a player and an investor, maybe you spend the money for the 59. A 59 is considered by most to be the pinnacle of the ES model and it will move up ahead of the rest of the market. It always has and while I can’t say it always will, it’s a pretty good bet. A ’59 is likely a better investment than a ’60. If you’re a player first and an investor second or you don’t care about the appreciation potential, then buy the early 60 and save the money. For everyone, I always suggest they buy the guitar they want to play or the guitar that makes them a better player. Then you can worry about the investment value…or not. Just because a 335 is a mid to late 59 doesn’t make it better than an early to mid 60 because, for all intents and purposes, it’s the same. You want the big neck? Buy a late 58 or a 59. You won’t get a big neck 60 (there are few but not many). But the cusp of 58 to 59 isn’t the same as 59 into 60. That’s another post.

Here’s a later 60. What you can see are the reflector knobs and the double ring tuners. What you can’t see is the much slimmer neck. The 60 up top has a neck that measures .84″ and .95″. This one is .79″ and .89″. Doesn’t seem like much-just a few hundredths of an inch but you’ll know when you pick it up.

Verified by MonsterInsights