RSS

Myths and Truths

February 26th, 2026 • Uncategorized • 12 Comments »

One of the things I really like about guitar folks is their belief in magic. There are so many urban legends, myths, assumptions and magical thinking that they sometimes play a bigger role in the purchase of a vintage guitar than the science (and reality). So, let’s have some fun with them. And don’t take my word for what is myth and what is real. I only know what my eyes and ears tell me and that might not be the same thing that you get from your eyes and ears. Let’s start with ears.

Old wood sounds better than new wood. Real. Old wood grew more slowly making for tighter grain and more density. New wood is is generally grown much more quickly making it less dense. Since sound travels through a solid better than through a liquid or a gas, it makes sense that old wood is more resonant. Another factor is moisture. The moisture in new and old wood is, I believe, about the same at the outset. But old wood has had more time to dry out and, again I believe that dryer wood is more resonant than moist wood. “Roasting” of wood kind of proves this to me.

One of the reasons that Les Paul “burst” conversions are so popular is that old wood sounds different (some would say better) than new wood. There is science behind this. Old wood is drier and old wood generally grew more slowly making it denser. I’m a big believer in old wood.

Ebony fingerboard has more “snap” than rosewood. Myth. First of all, there isn’t a whole lot of either in ES guitars (and most others) so the idea is that there is a difference in the actual tonal quality of the wood. True if the guitar is made from this wood. But a thin piece of ebony isn’t likely to change much of anything in the tone department. I believe most folks think the snap has to do with the response of the strings when pressed down on a piece of ebony rather than rosewood. Actually, you’re pressing down on the frets, not the wood. I have pretty good ears. I don’t have perfect pitch but I have a well developed sense of frequency, timbre and pitch. I’ve played dozens and dozens of ebony board ES-355’s and hundreds of rosewood board 335’s. I don’t hear the snap. Maybe you do. More power to you.

The fingerboard on this ES-355 is ebony. It is harder than rosewood and a bit smoother too. The question is whether it actually has an effect on the tone of your guitar. I think not. The conventional wisdom is that it enhances the highs thus imparting more “snap” to your notes. I think not.

White PAFs sound better than black ones. Myth and Real. This is my theory and I think it makes a lot of sense. The amount of wire wound onto the coil of a PAF varied immensely back when they were made. There was no stop mechanism on the winders. The person operating the winder stopped when the bobbin appeared to be full. Most winders would likely stop well before the bobbin was totally full because if they went to far, they had to stop and unwind the excess wire or start over. I’m sure they had daily quotas and didn’t want unnecessary delays. Err on the side of caution as it were. The wire was dark brown-almost purple and the bobbin was black so it was hard to see just how close to the edge you were when winding the pickup. Enter the white bobbin and the same dark wire. Now the winder could see much more clearly how much room was left on the bobbin thus allowing for more turns and a “hotter” pickup. I have measured hundreds of PAFs and the white ones are consistently higher DCR. That doesn’t necessarily make a better sounding pickup-there a lots of factors but it certainly makes them different and, to my ears, often better sounding. Note-it’s a theory not a law. Perhaps the musings of someone with too much time on his hands.

This stripped ’59 ES-345 was my main player for a few years. It had three extra holes in the top and a load of other issues but it had a pair of factory installed double white PAFs and they sounded glorious. But did they sound glorious because they were white?

I’ll do one more and this, by far is my favorite. Early Marshall cabinets have a rather distinctive grill cloth. Jimi Hendrix often used these cabinets with the “pinstripe” grill cloth. It’s kind of fragile and it’s become somewhat mythical. Mythical grill cloth? Well, apparently there are folks who believe that Hendrix’s distinctive guitar tone is due to his excellent playing passing through this “mythical” grill cloth. Is it possible for grill cloth to influence tone? Maybe. I don’t know but if it does, I don’t believe it would be to the extent that you can actually hear a distinctive difference. More likely, some grill cloths are more transparent than others so maybe some tone could be impeded by an overly dense cloth. But c’mon, Hendrix’s tone is because of the grill cloth? Hey, you know, I have this bridge in Brooklyn and it’s for sale for cheap…I can make you a deal…

Who knew that the Stratocaster was the Breakfast of Champions? But Jimi’s real secret weapon is the “pinstripe” grill cloth. Without it, Jimi was just another picker.

I’m sure there are lots more of these guitars driven myths and if you have one, send it to me or make a comment. I love this stuff.

Solder Whispering

February 9th, 2026 • Uncategorized • 1 Comment »

Original solder will generally look like this. It is fairly dull and generally neatly done. Look at the edge of the pickup cover as well. If it’s bent-even a little-you can be pretty certain that the cover has been off. That can be totally benign or it can mean the pickup has been repaired or rewound

There are lots of things to look for when you assess an old (or vintage) guitar for its value, collectability, and playability and I’ve written about just about all of them. What I haven’t discussed is solder. The solder itself doesn’t play much of a role-it simply holds metal parts together. But it can tell us things that would otherwise be the subject of speculation and an educated guess. I depend on solder to inform me of the originality and status of the pickups, the harness components and even the source of the Bigsby tailpiece.

I am often asked to assess the value and originality of vintage 335’s. I recently was sent a very nice vintage 335 in 9/10 condition with great playability. The average buyer would likely have bought it without hesitation. Everything looked right to an untrained eye. I usually look at the back of the pickups right away to see whether the covers have been off. How do I determine that? Solder. If it’s sloppy, then it is likely that the covers have been off. If it’s clean looking and shiny, it’s likely the covers have been off. Solder, after 65 years, won’t be shiny. It will be dull. That was the situation with the guitar I recently assessed. The solder was perfect and perfectly shiny. Even so, I wasn’t convinced that the covers had been off. I needed more proof. The knowledge that the pickup covers have been removed doesn’t tell us very much…it simply gives us a starting point from which to assess the state of the pickup. If the solder is original, they can’t have been rewound. I should make the point that it’s possible they were rewound, say 50 years ago and the covers expertly reinstalled and soldered. Let’s leave that for the moment. There aren’t a lot of reasons to remove a pickup cover. Lots of us, in the early 70’s, removed our pickup covers because we thought we were getting a bit more output from them without the covers (and we probably were). Eric Clapton removed the covers from his guitars so the rest of us, sheep that we are, did it as well. The only other reason to remove a pickup cover is to repair it which usually means a rewind. That, in and of itself, isn’t a terrible thing…I’ve had rewound PAFs that sound glorious. But if you are a collector or investor, originality counts for a lot so it’s important to know if the pickups might have been rewound.

There is solder in the harness as well. Again, shiny is a good indicator of newer solder. Remnants of old solder tells us a lot as well. But once we have determined that the solder isn’t original, what have we learned? It could be that the solder joint had deteriorated and the connection was no longer good. That requires new solder to re-establish the connection between components. Of particular importance is the solder to the volume pots. That’s where the pickups are connected in a 335 (but not in a 345 or stereo 355). If the solder to the back of the pot is disturbed but the solder to the lug where the pickup is connected is intact, then it probably was a repair to the ground (the braided part of the wire). If both are disturbed, it might mean the pickup has been out of the guitar. But how can we know that? We go back to the solder on the pickup cover. If it’s intact, it might mean that the pickup was replaced-not a big deal to a player if it’s the same era and type of pickup. It is kind of a big deal to a collector (again, originality is important). If the solder to the cover has been disturbed or replaced, then there’s a very high probability that the pickup was removed from the guitar, repaired or rewound and reinstalled. Going back to the 335 I was assessing, I looked at the bridge pickup volume pot and, sure enough, the solder had been disturbed. It was shiny and not as neat as the pickup cover solder. That told me the pickup had been removed.

It can get tricky though. The bridge pickup has clearly been opened. This is a 345 converted to mono, so we can assume that the cover was removed to flip the magnet to put the pickups in phase. But the neck pickuphas a rather different pattern of soldering where the base plate is roughed up and the solder hugs the gap between the cover and the plate. I’ve seen that at least two dozen times. I think it’s factory. Not everybody has the same solder technique.

There is lots of solder in the harness that isn’t related to the pickups and that’s important as well. Most folks don’t want to pull the harness out of a 335. It’s fiddly, difficult work and I don’t blame anyone for simply leaving it alone. I don’t generally remove the harness when going through a 335. But I do check the solder with a dental mirror and I usually detach the bridge pickup volume and tone and pull them into the f-hole to, what else, look at the solder. You want to make sure the components are all original. If the correct parts have been used, the only way to tell if there has been activity in there is to look at the solder. Does it matter if the three way is replaced? Probably not. Same goes for the jack. If the pot codes match, it probably doesn’t matter much if a pot was replaced. There is a good indicator of work having been done on a harness. Look for the lock washers on the pots. If any are missing, then somebody (and probably not a professional) has been in there. They get left out a lot. Nothing to do with solder-just something to look for while you’re in there.

And what about that situation where the pickup was rewound decades ago and the solder was expertly redone? If the edges of the covers aren’t bent, then there is no way to know if work was done. If the pickup is correct and the solder looks right, I go with the odds and my ears. Odds are it’s OK. It’s a little like a replaced bridge or tailpiece (or any other part that is replaceable without a trace)…If it’s correct, don’t worry about it. You can look at wear and patina and that might tell you something but that’s another post.

The solder looks pretty good but the cover for the neck pickup looks disturbed. It’s always possible that one pickup was worked on and the other is original and intact. That might be the case here but dollars to donuts, that neck pickup cover has been off. Time to look at the harness to get more evidence.

Is it Nickel or Chrome?

January 17th, 2026 • Gibson General, Parts • 4 Comments »
One of these is nickel. The other is chrome. They look totally different to me and should to you. If they don’t, they have handy labels to help you.

Guitar hardware is something most folks don’t give much thought to. Most folks accept whatever hardware is on the guitar and don’t take it any further. Yeah, every once in a while, you come across a 345 or a 355 that had its gold hardware swapped out for nickel but, in most cases folks just leave it alone. Guitar players love to mess with their gear-especially electronics-but hardware is kind of a who cares. There will always be those who will swap out hardware as soon as the slightest bit of wear shows. These are the same folks who wipe down their guitar after every set and won’t let you even pick their guitar up to check it out. You know who you are.

From 1958 to early 1965, the hardware on a 335 was nickel plated. From 1965 until 1981, it was chrome.

I really like nickel hardware. It’s elegant yet subtle. It’s not showy like gold and not gaudy like chrome. Really? Chrome is gaudy? Most folks can’t tell the difference between untarnished nickel and chrome. I think it’s time you learned the difference if only if it stops you from replacing the worn parts on your 64 ES-335 with (gasp) chrome. I’ve seen it way too often. Gibson used nickel plated hardware on the first ES-335’s rather than chrome. I don’t know what their reasoning was but I’m guessing that nickel was either cheaper at the time or the cost of the plating process was cheaper or both. The new 1958 335’s looked great. Newly plated nickel parts are very attractive and quite durable. But nickel, especially when exposed to sweat, skin oils and cleaners, will tarnish. Apparently folks didn’t like their hardware to look dull or discolored so they employed a very American consumer convention…they complained. They complained from 1958 until 1965 when Gibson threw in the towel and switched to chrome plated parts.

This is a 66 ES-335 in factory black. Chrome parts look pretty good next to a black guitar but I think nickel would look even better

It can be a little tricky to tell nickel from chrome if you don’t have examples of both in front of you, especially when the nickel is new. The simple way to tell nickel from chrome is to look at it. Nickel reflects light in the green spectrum. Chrome reflects blue. It’s not glaring. It’s fairly subtle, particularly when you’re looking at very small guitar parts like a tailpiece. Or you can determine whether the reflection is warm or cold. Chrome is a very cold look-cold like a hospital OR. Is it tarnished? A yes means it’s nickel. Chrome doesn’t tarnish. It can corrode but corrosion rarely occurs on guitar parts unless there has been some chemical reaction (like off gassing of celluloid).

I was shopping with my wife for a bathroom renovation and I was struck by how obvious the difference between chrome and nickel is on larger items. So, I took a photo. It should be glaringly obvious which faucet set is nickel and which is chrome. If you still can’t tell, ask your doctor to do a color blind test. It was a no brainer…we (she) chose the nickel.

I like nickel hardware on my guitars. Maybe that’s part of why I find Gibson guitars more attractive than some others. Fender has always used chrome and while it looks just fine, I think it might look better in nickel. There isn’t a lot of plated hardware on a Strat or a Tele but a Jaguar or Jazz Bass has quite a lot. The pickup covers on a bass (if you don’t remove them) get a lot of contact with skin and that means sweat and oil which will eventually dull out your nickel parts. So, from a practical standpoint, maybe Fender got it right. But if you value aesthetics over practicality (like I do) then nickel is your choice.

Of course, there are other choices. The very first PAF pickup covers were brushed stainless steel. They looked quite good but for some reason they didn’t make it out of 1957. Again, probably cost. There are lots of guitars with gold plated parts. I think many people find gold to be classy. I find it kind of ostentatious. If I walk into someone’s guest bathroom and it has gold fixtures (not brass), I instantly form an opinion about the taste of the homeowner. The problem with gold parts is that gold is crazy expensive these days and the thickness of the gold plating has become so thin that you can rub it off in a couple of minutes with your thumb. The vintage Gibsons have a much thicker gold plating but the gold still wears off fairly quickly. I’ve had a number of guitars that would qualify for the “dead mint” designation if not for worn (not tarnished-gold doesn’t tarnish) hardware.

The gold plating on this ES-355 is remarkably clean. It shows no wear at all. Out of all of the vintage guitars I’ve owned (over 600), this is the only one with gold hardware that I could call “dead mint”.

A guitar with nickel plated parts won’t sound any different than one with gold or chrome plated parts. I’ve actually heard arguments that revolve around the effect of certain metals on the magnetic field of a pickup. But guitar players are, by nature, an argumentative bunch. Read any guitar forum. Put ten guitar players in a room with one guitar and you will get ten different opinions about what is wrong with the guitar (especially when there is nothing wrong). You gotta love that.

Vintage or Just Old?

January 8th, 2026 • Uncategorized • 3 Comments »

Not all 70’s Gibsons are bad guitars. The 76-77 Explorers mostly got it right. The rest of the lines struggled. They simply aren’t nearly as good as the guitars from the 60’s. Lots of reasons and no excuses.

Is it the end of another year already? They seem to go faster every year. It seems like I was in my 50’s a minute ago and now, somehow, I’m in my 70’s. It’s also interesting that as years go by, the definition of “vintage” doesn’t change much. A guitar from the mid 90’s is 30 years old. That used to be a marker for vintage in the 90’s. But nobody is calling 90’s guitars that. Or 80’s guitars for that matter. If your definition of vintage is simply a certain age (which makes some sense), then it should change yearly or perhaps by the decade. Pretty much everybody agrees that guitars built in the 50’s and most of the 60’s are particularly good and few would dispute the term vintage for that era. But the build quality in the 70’s-with few exceptions-was generally pretty terrible. To most of us, the sale of Fender and Gibson to large corporations signaled the end of the “Golden Era”. But is that going to be the only era referred to as vintage? Let’s take a look at some guitars from the 70’s and 80’s that haven’t gotten much positive attention and a few that perhaps deserve a second look.

This one came and went pretty quickly. It is the ES-369. Only made from 1980-82. It was, essentially a 335 with a coil tap switch, “Dirty Fingers” pickups which were a pretty hot ceramic type and a TP6 tailpiece. Build quality was mediocre. They are generally pretty heavy (9 lbs+)

Gibson was sold to Norlin (beer, concrete) in 1969. Most call that the beginning of a long downhill slide that marked the clear end of an era. Gibson had some colossal flops but they also made some pretty good guitars in the 70’s and early 80’s (although I can only think of a few). The 76 Explorers can be wonderful players although the necks can be ridiculously large. There are folks who love the L6S. I’m not one of them. Then there’s the Sonex (actually not a 70’s but close enough). A bad idea poorly executed. It was, essentially, made of cardboard. Enough said. The ES line had some new additions and failures abound. It wasn’t that they were particularly bad designs (although there were a few) but that the build quality and materials were generally awful. You don’t hear too many folks looking for an ES-325 (a cheapo 335) or an ES-369, a nice try at an upscale 335 but apparently not nice enough. I kind of like the Dirty Fingers pickup-a nod, of sorts to DiMarzio who pretty much owned the pickup market in the 80’s. If we get to the early 80’s, we see the reissue of the 335 dot. Good guitars but not as good as the original. An 81-85 ES-335 commands a decent price-much more than other Gibson from the era. The Les Paul line in the 70’s struggled to find its footing after the very successful reintroduction of the LP Standard in 68. Perhaps the most striking thing about the Les Paul line during the period is that it went downhill every year throughout the 70’s. It’s as if someone was saying “how can we make these wonderful guitars cheaper and crappier every year?” The 68’s were close to the 50’s LP P90 Standard. The 69 went to the ugly big headstock and then to the three piece neck and then to the volute. By 70, the tenon was shorter and the body wasn’t one piece any more. By 71, the tenon had just about disappeared and the volute got bigger. That’s what happens when bean counters are in charge. Bean counters don’t know much about tone. They are “businessmen” who didn’t belong in the music business.

Ugly, heavy, poorly designed and poorly built, the RD was introduced in 1977. One of the ugliest guitars ever made. The RD Artist was particularly awful- the Moog electronics are horrible.

There are a lot more Gibsons that were introduced in the 70’s and 80’s and they really have been relegated to the dustbin of guitar history. Take the RD line. Please. Bad design and bad execution and, in the case of the RD Artist, bad electronics. It’s an ugly, ungainly slab of wood disguised as a guitar. I’m told there are folks who love them. By all means, enjoy. I’m surprised the line lasted as long as it did-especially the RD Artist. In fact, you can take all the models with the Moog electronics and burn them as far as I’m concerned. I bought an ES Artist a few years ago because I thought with all my knowledge, I could make it sound good. I could not. It was horrible. Then, there’s the Marauder, a solid body two or three pickup bolt on neck guitar that had very limited success and was discontinued after 6 years. The US-1 model was a Strat copy and was pretty awful (I had one in the 90’s). It was Gibson’s entry into the “Superstrat” era that, happily, went away after a few years.

Wow, Gibson makes a Stratocaster. I owned one. It was awful. Maybe if the pickups were better, it would have been ok. It was lifeless and dull. The US-1 lasted from 86 until 91.

Beyond Gibson, the 70’s and 80’s were not the best era for guitars. Gretsch’s are wonderful until 1962 and the downhill slog starts slowly-62-64 Gents can be pretty good (ask George). Rickenbackers never seem to change-I’ve played a few from the 70’s and 80’s that were pretty close to the earlier models. Electric Guilds from the 70’s fell out of favor while the Guild acoustics (especially 12 strings) saw real success. Martins from the 70’s can be very good but they can also be pretty bad, Changes in manufacturing and structure caused some intonation issues. A change from hide glue to a “modern” glue apparently made some sound dull. I’m told that in ’71, there were misplaced bridges that caused intonation issues. The rumor of a major fire wiping out all of the Brazilian rosewood is apparently an urban myth. The biggest factor at Martin and to an extent, all of the manufacturers is trying to build too many guitars too quickly resulting in QC issues across the board. I’ll leave it there…I’m really not qualified to assess these manufacturers since I don’t play that many. There are folks with much more knowledge than I have who can write the history of Fender in the post CBS era, so I’ll stay out that arena as well.

This is the Gibson Sonex 180. The high tech body material was called “Resonwood” which is essentially, sawdust and glue. Great idea. Weighed a ton. Lasted from 1980-1984. Not vintage. Thanks to Howie Statland at Rivington Guitars for the photo (“borrowed” off Reverb).

Does vintage have to mean good? I think so. An antique can be simply old, I suppose but vintage seems to suggest quality-especially a quality that no longer exists. If that is true, then guitars from the 70’s might never be considered vintage. Just old. As long as the guitars from a given era are inferior to the guitars of a previous era, then the term vintage might never apply. Just my opinion. I don’t make the rules.

“Twas”…(Again)

December 19th, 2025 • Uncategorized • No Comments »
This was the home of OK Guitars from 2015 until 2020. It was known as the “Caboose” but it was actually a baggage car.

This is the only blog post I ever rerun. My wife and I wrote this together while on vacation in Mexico at Christmas in 2015. Every year I reread it thinking it’s kind of dopey and every year I rerun it because it’s not as dopey as I remember. Here you go. If it’s too dopey, too bad. You’ll get it again next year.

The OK Guitars Christmas tree at “The Caboose” in Kent, CT. Yes, it had a theme complete with the traditional star(r) on top. The shop is gone now and we no longer live in Kent. We miss it.

The Night Before Christmas at OK Guitars

‘Twas the night before Christmas and all through the pad

I was playing my Gibson- not great, but not bad.

I remembered a blues lick and played it with flair

Just like in the days when I had all my hair.

The block necks were hung not too tight or too loose,

As I waited for Santa inside my caboose.

I had them all tuned and I played every one.

The truss rods were perfect, the strings tightly strung.

**********************************************

All of a sudden on the roof of my shop,

I spied an old fat dude just reeking of pot.

He fell off the roof and into the snow.

I asked him right in. Why he came, I don’t know.

There was ice in his beard and mud on his boot,

And I thought only rock stars could wear such a suit.

He took down a red one, just like Eric C.

His fingers flew faster than old Alvin Lee.

***********************************************

It was wailing and screaming all over the town.

I could hear my Dad yelling, “Turn that damn thing down!”

Who knew this weird guy, such a flash with a pick

And a love of guitars, would be old Saint Nick?

I couldn’t believe all the sounds in my ear.

He said, “You get good working one day a year.”

Now Jimi, Now BB, Now John, George and Paul

Would bow to this master, the best of them all.

************************************************

“You remember that Christmas back in ’63?

When you found a new six string left under your tree?

You started to doubt that I was the truth,

But my gift to you then was a link to your youth.

So for all of the years that would come in between,

Way deep down inside, you’d still feel like sixteen.”

He picked up some cases by Lifton and Stone,

Some old Kluson tuners and a worn out Fuzztone.

************************************************

“Now, Charlie Gelber you must hear my pitch,

‘Cause this is my time and payback’s a bitch.

The 335 please, the red 59.

I gave you your first one, now this ax is mine”.

And quick as a flash it was stuffed in his sack,

And he waved a goodbye as he snuck out the back.

He jumped in his sled and sparked up a j,

Flew into the sky and was off on his way.

So if feeling sixteen is what sets you right,

Merry Christmas to all, and to all a good night.

By Charlie and Victoria Gelber

With apologies to Clement Clark Moore

No Christmas tree is complete without the traditional Starr on top.

Underappreciated

December 11th, 2025 • Uncategorized • 6 Comments »

This 60 Gretsch 6120 is a great player that will do just about anything a 335 will do except intonate properly. That’s really the only weakness of this “second tier” vintage guitar. Buy one for around $10K but don’t expect it to appreciate like a Gibson or a Fender

As a dealer, I get to play a lot of guitars. Most of them are Gibsons and Fenders which shouldn’t be surprising as these are the brands that lead the vintage market for electric guitars. Most players understand that there are many guitars that are every bit as good as these but they just don’t get the love and appreciation (both kinds) that these two companies get. You can add Martin to this category if we include acoustics.

Gretsch is a great example. Many guitars get their cachet from having been played by a revered player. Eric Clapton played a 335 for a very important part of his career, so the 64 ES-335 (especially in red) became a very desirable vintage investment and collectors piece. Oddly, the 63 Gretsch Country Gentleman as played by George Harrison during a very important part of his career, isn’t considered a good investment and, by many, a good player. I think they are decent players but they don’t really come close to a 64 335. That said, there are Gretsch’s that are deserving of a place in any vintage collection. They are not, for the most part, great investment pieces. The best example of this (in my opinion) is the 6120, especially those with the trestle bracing. I’ve had a number of ’60 and ’61 6120’s that have been as good as any guitar I’ve owned. Unfortunately virtually all of them have a Bigsby which is not something I’m fond of and they have a bar type bridge which is impossible to intonate. These 6120’s are not cheap but compared to a 64 ES-335, they aren’t exactly pricey. A clean Bigsby 64 ES-335 will cost you around $25,000 to $30,000. A 59 to 61 6120 will cost you less than half that. I also like the Duo Jets with the DeArmond pickups. I like the 6120’s with DeArmonds as well. I don’t like anything made by Gretsch after 1962. The quality suffered from 62 on probably due to too many orders and not enough skilled workers to fill those orders. After the Beatles were on Ed Sullivan, the sales of Gents went through the roof. Today, a 63-64 Gent will cost you anywhere from $4000 to $7000 depending on condition (bindings are a big problem) and which pickups it has (two Filtertrons-like George’s- is more desirable than one Filtertron and one Supertron). Build quality after 65 gets inconsistent and somewhat dicey.

One of my favorites of the “second tier” vintage guitars is the Epiphone Sheraton from 1959 to 1965. Until recently, you could get a blonde for around $10K. The later ones with mini humbuckers are less expensive and great guitars. Still a bargain if you ask me.

There are a lot of other American brands that were popular and highly regarded during the 50’s to mid 60’s. Guild, Rickenbacker, Epiphone (USA) and even Harmony for those with a limited budget. There were also non American guitars like Vox, Burns, Hagstrom and Hofner that were popular but perhaps not considered, in hindsight, as particularly good players. Vintage Guilds from the late 50’s like the Aristocrat, the Duane Eddy and the Thunderbird can run with the big boys for a fraction of the price. A Gibson made Epiphone made from ’59 to ’69 is nearly identical to many of the Gibsons built by the same workers in the same factory as the Gibson we all love. I’ll take a Sheraton from 59 to 65 over most guitars other than a 335, 345 or 355. I’ll take an Epiphone Wilshire over any P90 guitar made with the Gibson name on it.

\

In my opinion, the solid body Epiphones made from 1959 until 1963 are the most underrated guitars ever made. The P90 guitars (Wilshire and Coronet) are simply amazing. My ’60 Wilshire(far right) will go to the grave with me. The one in front is the excellent limited edition reissue made in USA by the Gibson Custom Shop in 2009.

Rickenbacker is kind of a special case because they owned the 12 string market during this era but only had a tiny portion of the six string market. It always shocks me (yes, shocks) that a Ricky 325 isn’t a much more valuable guitar. They are rare, it was played by John Lennon (and John Fogerty) and they are really good players if you can manage a short scale guitar. I bought one not too long ago for $8000. There are a few on the market now at $10,000 to $13,000. I’m surprised they aren’t five times that much.

This image requires no explanation

Simply having been played by a famous guitar player isn’t enough by itself to place a guitar into the vintage stratosphere. It seems you have to be a Gibson or a Fender and have a famous player on board to get there. There are holes in that theory. Les Paul wasn’t a guitar hero to my generation. Three Beatles played Epiphone Casinos and they have, to an extent, reached rarefied vintage status but the other Beatle guitars simply have not. Hofner basses were popular for a minute in the mid to late 60’s. But it didn’t last. Same with Country Gentlemen. Ricky 325’s were never all that popular. A famous surf band called The Ventures played Fenders until they made a deal with a little company called Mosrite. The Mosrite guitars were prominently displayed on every Ventures album after the deal was made. They were very expensive (more than the equivalent Fender) and never gained the following that Mosrite surely hoped for. I played one from 1969 until 1974. The neck is so slim that it’s nearly impossible to play without altering your fingering and hand position. But they sound great and look cooler than almost anything out there. I still have one. They are not expensive. You can get a 64-66 Ventures Model for $4000 to $6000. An early one (set neck, side jack, body binding) will cost you twice that but the cool factor is even higher.

This is my personal Mosrite sidejack from 1963. My short, stubby fingers are ill suited for this guitar but the cool factor, in my opinion, is off the charts.

Standoff (Again)

November 27th, 2025 • Uncategorized • 3 Comments »
What is this very nice 1961 ES-335 worth these days? Is it $60,000 like the one on Reverb? Or maybe $52,500 like another on Reverb? It’s very clean with no issues and sold not long ago for $37,500. Either somebody got a steal or folks are asking too much for 61’s. I strongly suspect the latter.

It happens every couple of years-usually after a strong runup in prices. Sellers (dealers too) think the vintage market will continue to climb long after it has reached its peak. I don’t think for a minute that I can predict a market top (I’d be rich if I could) but I can see a market that has flattened out simply by looking at the number of sales that I make. I pay a lot of attention to that and to which guitars are selling (and which guitars are not). The huge runup that occurred during Covid is long over but prices have continued to rise while sales have not. I’ve been cutting prices on certain guitars fairly aggressively and some are selling but many are not even when they are 10 to 15% below the competition. That is usually the result of a lack of trust among buyers. They simply don’t believe the particular guitar they are after could possibly be that much money and, in large part, they are correct. Asking prices on many of the most desirable guitars have doubled in the past 5 to 6 years. Sales, however, aren’t even close to the level that occurred during Covid. Lots of reasons for that, not the least of which is there wasn’t much to do when you are stuck indoors for months on end. Covid ended (well it didn’t end but the restrictions did) and the guitar market somehow missed it. Asking prices have kept rising and many have reached absurd levels. Examples? You want examples? I’ve got ’em.

Before Covid, I could expect to get $25,000 for a 1961 ES-335 is all original 9/10 condition. My spreadsheet shows I sold two 61’s in 2020 (I don’t sell that many 61’s but it’s a good example). A red stop tail in 9-/10 condition sold for $23,000. A near mint red stop tail sold for $32,000. At the end of Covid, I sold a few more-a near mint stop tail for $39,900 and a museum grade, long guard early 61 for $47K. Let’s use the near mint ones as the best examples. A rise from 32,000 to around $40,000 is a pretty good run for a two and a half year period. That’s 25% if you’re doing the math. Today, I’m looking at prices for near mint/excellent stop tail 61’s. A month ago, the highest was $68,000 which is around another 25% higher than the end of Covid. The next highest was $58,000. Then there’s another at $55K, another at $54K and one at $52,500. Now, I don’t have a 61 right now but I sold one for $40,000 less than 6 months ago. I’ve never gotten more than $40,000 for a 61 unless it had a long guard.

Here’s a nice 60 ES-345. These have gotten out of control too. Great guitars but $56K? Really?

Another great example is a 60 ES-345. Before Covid, I sold one for $18,000. During Covid, I sold one in similar condition for $24,000. Prices on Reverb today? One for $56,000, another for $45,000, another for $37,400. I don’t think the value of a 60 ES-345 has run up 50% since Covid. But wait a minute…don’t I have one ( a Bigsby no less) listed for $37,500? I do and it requires some explanation. It’s a one off Custom (one of a kind) built in 59 (59 FON) and shipped in January 60. If it wasn’t the only mono, no Varitone ES-345 I’ve ever seen, it would be more like $28,000. I’ve priced it like a 335 because it is a 335 with a 345 label and gold hardware. What makes a 345 a 345 is the Varitone and the stereo circuit. Gibson called it a 345 (they could charge more) but this one is a true custom and has aspects of 335, 345 and 355. I just felt I had to explain why mine was a high priced as it is. A 60 335 is currently a lot more than $37,500. But I digress…

The larger point here is that the market has stalled because so many sellers are asking way more than the buyers are willing to spend and until prices moderate, that will continue. What will cause prices to moderate is anybody’s guess. I’ve been steadily lowering prices on all but the highest grade collector guitars-those are still selling. The consignments are priced by the owners. Guitars are still selling but not like they should be. Everybody needs to take breath and read the tea leaves. Vintage guitars are (and have been for some time) a great investment. You don’t make any money having them sit on Reverb or elsewhere with a price that nobody will pay. There are no billionaire suckers on the sidelines waiting for exactly what you are selling-largely because billionaires are more careful with their money than just about anyone. That has a lot to do with how they manage to become billionaires.

Are bursts immune to the ups and downs of the vintage market? It sure looks that way. Even in 2008, when just about everything from watches to houses to guitars took a dive, bursts held on better than everything else. This “double 0” sold last year for a lot of money. I’ll bet it’s worth another 15% today. This is where the billionaires play.

Lucy, I’m Home…

October 19th, 2025 • Gibson General • 1 Comment »

George playing his beloved “Lucy”. Just a refinished 57 Goldtop and one of the most famous guitars on Earth.

I’ll move away from 335’s for a bit because I just got in a whole load of Les Paul conversions. Two of them are unusual in that they were converted to look like George Harrison’s well known Les Paul, nicknamed “Lucy”. I’ll get to that in a minute but first some history. At the height of Beatlemania, John, Paul, George and Ringo could afford any gear they wanted and, being Beatles, every instrument maker was clamoring for them to use their products-free of charge, of course. It is interesting that the guitars they first used were not particularly popular here in the USA (until the Beatles used them). Gretsch was well known but not at the level of Fender and Gibson. Once we all saw George playing his Country Gentleman on Ed Sullivan, sales went through the roof. Stratocasters were later acquired by John and George as were three Epiphone Casinos. Sales of those also went way up although Stratocasters were already wildly popular thanks to Buddy Holly and a zillion other players in the late 50’s and early 60’s. The Gibson Les Paul simply wasn’t a popular guitar at this time. A few British players discovered them as did John Sebastian of the Lovin’ Spoonful. The first time I ever saw a Les Paul was in 1966 in the hands of John Sebastian on “Shindig” on ABC or maybe it was “Hullabaloo” on NBC. The fact that no Beatle played one until 1968 isn’t that surprising. They simply weren’t very popular. Lucy was the first Les Paul owned by a Beatle. Paul still owns one (a lefty, of course).

According to Wikipedia, the Lucy guitar, in its goldtop finish, was previously owned by Skip Boone, brother of Steve Boone of the Lovin’ Spoonful. It is my understanding that it was also owned by John Sebastian of the Lovin’ Spoonful. Still a goldtop, it was sold to Rick Derringer of the 60’s pop group, The McCoys who had a few hits and Derringer went on to have a long solo career as both a player and a producer. The 57 Gibson Les Paul goldtop (SN 7-8789) was getting kind of beat up and he was convinced to have it refinished. It was sent to Gibson to have the top refinished in the translucent red that was popular at the time. When he got it back, he didn’t like it so much any more although no one knows exactly why.

Derringer traded it in at Dan Armstrong’s shop In Greenwich Village and, shortly after Armstrong acquired it, it was bought by Eric Clapton. Nobody cared much about refinishes back then. It was simply, a used guitar. Clapton never bonded with it and he gifted it in 1968 to his good friend, George Harrison. George, who didn’t seem the type to name his guitars, named this one “Lucy”. It was red, after all, and the world’s most famous redhead was one Lucille Ball. George had started to move away from the Gretsch’s he famously played in the early days. He and John had acquired Stratocasters in 65 and he painted his in psychedelic day glo colors and called it Rocky (maybe he was the type to name his guitars). Rocky saw a lot of hours in the studio. George acquired a Gibson SG around the time Paperback Writer was recorded and he was likely taken with the sound of Gibson’s humbucking pickups. His good friend Eric Clapton was certainly aware of this…he played an SG (“The Fool”) during much of the Cream era and also had a 60 Les Paul and a 64 ES-335 during that period. All humbucker equipped Gibsons.

When Clapton was invited to play on George’s “While my Guitar Gently Weeps”, he arrived at EMI without a guitar. George handed him “Lucy” and you know the rest. The story doesn’t end there, however. Lucy was one of George’s favorite guitars and it was stolen from his home in Los Angeles in 1973. By this time, George could certainly afford any guitar he wanted but he was set on getting Lucy back. It had been sold to a Mexican musician named Miguel Ochoa. After a lot of back and forth haggling, Ochoa agreed to take a 58 Les Paul burst and a Fender P-bass in trade for Lucy. Think about that-a real burst and a new P-Bass in trade for a refinished goldtop. George must have really liked that red guitar. George owned “Lucy” until his death in 2001. I believe the family still owns it.

George played Lucy for most of the white album and much of Abbey Road including the iconic “guitar duel” in Abbey Road’s “The End”-one of my favorite moments on any Beatles LP. Gibson reissued a copy of Lucy in 2007 and again in 2013. The range of prices for these reissues is insane. As much as $90,000 (2013-one of 100) and as little as $15,000 (2007 VOS finish). If you want a vintage version, there have been a few conversions made from 50’s goldtops like the original. As I mentioned, I have two of them. No fan worth his Beatle boots should be without one.

This is a converted 1952 center seam with a pair of double white PAFs. Conversion by Jim Weyandt

This one, also a center seam 52, looks a lot like the original Lucy. This one has double white PAFs as well. George’s Lucy did not. Jim Weyandt did this one as well.

Conversion

October 4th, 2025 • Gibson General, Uncategorized • 5 Comments »

There are conversions of all kinds-not just Les Pauls. This Ferrari Daytona makes the point more clearly than a guitar. They only made 122 convertibles but they made 1400 Berlinettas (coupes). So, some smart guy decided it made sense to cut the roof off of a $500,000 car and turn it into an $850,000 car. An original convertible? Two million and change. So, a conversion is less than half the price of the original. Sound familiar?

Conversions are nothing new. There is the religious kind and the football kind (a big deal here in Ohio). There is also a 335 conversion done by turning an EB-2 bass into a 335 (Ken McKay does those). But this post goes off topic a bit and talks about (gasp) Les Paul conversions. Yes, I’m being a bit self serving because, somehow, I have four of them in my inventory.

A great example that isn’t a guitar but makes the point rather well is the Ferrari Daytona. They made coupes (or Berlinettas) and they made convertibles (Spyders). Most of the 1400 or so that were built (oddly, a very similar number as Les Paul bursts) were Berlinettas and they got crazy expensive in the years between 1969 when they started building them and now. But the convertible was not only crazy expensive but crazy rare. There were only 122 of them made. Got an extra $2,000,000 or so? That’ll buy you one. Or you can buy a conversion (a Berlinetta with the top cut off and some body stiffening) for $850,000 or so. A 69-74 Berlinetta will cost around $500,000. So, a Spyder conversion is less than half the price of a real one. Sort of like a Les Paul conversion.

Most Les Paul conversions start as a goldtop. What’s under the gold is always something of a crapshoot. How many pieces is the top? Any figure/flame or birdseye? You can sometimes see a little figure in the control cavity but that doesn’t tell you much. The closer to a center seam, the better. rarely, there will be a one piece top but don’t hold your breath-it’s crazy rare. This 56/59 conversion done by Jim Weyandt has a one piece birdseye top. It is in my inventory and is for sale.

The problem with LP conversions is that they are not all created equal. Some are made by taking a LP Special or Jr and topping it with a maple cap and loading it up with repro hardware. These are relatively inexpensive but that type is more cosmetic than authentic. Or, you can take a 57 or 58 Goldtop with humbuckers and refinish it and sell it for well over $100,000 depending on the top. In between, the most common conversion is the 52-56 P90 Goldtop, stripped of its finish and rerouted for humbuckers. In so doing, you need to hope for an interesting top that isn’t made of too many pieces of maple. A center seam flamed top would be nice but that’s not common in GTs. There are one piece tops and there are three piece tops. The more pieces, the less desirable. There are plain tops and flame tops and birdseye tops. Some, like the 56’s don’t require too much work-just fill the P90 routs (they are slightly longer than humbucker routs and need to be filled) and rerout for humbuckers. A 52-53 conversion, which is one of the most common, requires a neck reset. A late 53/54/early 55 requires the wraptail holes to be filled and the top re-drilled for an ABR-1 and stop tail. Again, it’s a crapshoot when it comes to the very important top. You might see some flame on the backside of the top through the control rout but that doesn’t guarantee much. It could still be a multi piece top with seams in the wrong places. Another thing worth looking at when you are considering one is the conversion of the pickup routs. Some just enlarge the P90 rout leaving a small area unfilled (a P90 is wider than a humbucker. The really skilled guys will fill that tiny opening with a matching slice of maple. I look for that anytime I’m considering a conversion.

See that tiny piece of maple at the upper corner of the pickup rout? That’s how a P90 rout gets turned into a humbucker rout the right way. If you don’t have the skills to do that level of work, then don’t do your own conversion. This was done by Jim Weyandt (Jam City Guitars)

Next, what are the components like? PAFs are always a plus (and they are pricey). Plastic parts are crazy expensive so you rarely see a conversion with correct vintage pickup rings. You’ll often get an original pickguard cut to accommodate the wider humbuckers and maybe a proper vintage truss cover. Most goldtops had speed knobs so you’ll see plenty fo conversions with them. A set of burst knobs is expensive but I think your burst conversion should have them (or at least good repros). Now I’m going to make a point I’ve made a lot. Repro parts are often extremely accurate and most parts don’t make a lick of difference in the tone or playability of the guitar. A repro tailpiece or bridge will sound the same as the real thing. Plastic? Same deal. No effect on tone. It’s nice to get a conversion with all the correct burst parts but it’s gonna cost you. A short seam stop tail can run $3000. A set of back plates can cost the same. A set of pickup rings, if you can find them, might go for $20K. Crazy, right? Spend the money on the pickups and maybe the harness but save your money on the other parts if you are budget conscious.

Pay attention to who did the conversion. There are lots of luthiers who do them but the ones that seem to get the most attention are from Cris Mirabella, Terry Mueller, Jim Weyandt and Brian Monty. There are plenty of others who do quality work. Do your homework before buying based on looks alone. Personally, I would stick to converted gold tops if you’re looking to get the feel of a real burst. the Specials and Jrs can look right but to me, it’s still a Special or Jr. A maple top glued onto a Jr body is something but is it a Standard? I dunno. Doesn’t do it for me. A quality GT conversion with PAFs is going to cost you from perhaps $30,000 to maybe $125,000 depending on the donor guitar, the parts and the builder. Old wood is old wood and that’s the biggest reason to do a conversion (or buy one). A 58-60 burst is going to cost you $400,000 or more. Most of us don’t have anywhere near that to spend on a single guitar or, if we do, our wives or significant others would probably throw us out. It really depends what your goal is. If it’s an investment, buy a burst. Conversions don’t tend to appreciate like an original vintage guitar (although the parts certainly have).

Sometimes, you can get really lucky and get a center seam flame top (or very, very close to it) like this 52. They definitely exist but they are rare. This conversion was done by Cris Mirabella. This one is also in the OK inventory.

Finally, there are a lot of folks who believe it’s sacrilege to take a vintage guitar and convert it. Not me. Most of the conversions begin with a trashed donor guitar. Lots of guitars have already been refinished and there is no reason not to do a conversion in that case. The same goes for a guitar with a major repair-the vintage value is already diminished by close to half anyway so why not convert it? I think the burst market is insane (and yet I still buy and sell one or two a year). I also think a burst is a really excellent guitar (not my favorite but I like them). The conversion can get you very close to an original. So can an R9 but if you believe that old wood makes a difference (and I do), then a conversion might be the ticket. One more point…you could argue that a 25 year old R9 is old wood. That’s plenty of time for it to dry out and open up. But old wood is more than just old. Old wood is old growth as well. Twenty five year old wood is not. But that’s another post.

“Lucy, I’m home…” OK, you aren’t old enough to remember that reference. This conversion copies the Eric Clapton/George Harrison guitar that was converted from a 57 goldtop. This one is a 52. The advantage of a 52/early 53 is that there are no holes in the top to be filled (like a 54-55). A “Lucy” is a cool alternative when you have a plain top donor guitar. This was also done by Jim Weyandt (and is also in the OK inventory).

Crack

September 28th, 2025 • ES 335, ES 345, ES 355 • 1 Comment »
That benign looking little line isn’t so benign. Sellers will call it a check, a scratch, a grain separation or anything else they can think of except for what it is-a truss rod crack caused by overtightening the truss rod, especially in a blade neck 61. It isn’t the end of the world and it’s fixable.

It’s kind of an ugly word and it has lots of ugly connotations. A crack kills an awful lot of guitar deals and often, it kills them for me. But there are an awful lot of ways that wood can crack and some are a lot worse than others. It’s important to understand what cracks are benign or cosmetic and what cracks are a flashing red light with sirens and bells. Wood is durable and fragile at the same time. It can be extremely flexible and extremely rigid. It will take a lot of abuse but only up to a point and then it gives up, usually all at once.

Wood has grain and is weaker along the grain lines. A quarter sawn neck takes advantage of the strength across the grain and makes for a stable, strong neck. The cracks we see in a guitar neck are often the result of trauma. The guitar falls off the stand and the headstock cracks (or breaks off). No wood will withstand a fall every time. Headstock cracks can be an easy fix with little effect on the playability and tone once properly glued up. They can also be impossible to fix. The conventional wisdom is that the glue is stronger than the wood. That’s true but only if the repair is done properly. That’s another post. I generally avoid guitars with headstock repairs but I’ve had plenty of them over the years that have caused no problems at all. The ones I have had that have caused me trouble usually re-break right at the repair which, of course, calls the conventional wisdom into question.

Another common neck break, especially in 335’s, is the truss rod crack. Guitars with a very slim (front to back) depth have very little wood between the truss rod and the back of the neck. When overtightened, the neck will crack vertically-usually along the grain. The crack usually starts at the third fret or so and can extend from 1″ to as much as 14″ in a very straight line. Folks call it a check, a scratch…anything but a crack. A crack means big trouble to most folks. But a truss rod crack really isn’t that big of a deal. It’s really mostly cosmetic. There is very little stress in that direction-the force vector of a strung up guitar is perpendicular to the neck (remember your high school physics). So, it isn’t likely to get worse unless you overtighten the truss rod again. I’ve had my luthier float a little super glue in there but that’s not even necessary in most cases.

Sticking with 335 cracks, there is another type that is largely cosmetic but cause all sorts of anxiety in buyers. A top crack on an acoustic guitar is kind of a big deal. The top is what generates most of the sound and a crack will diminish that. In a 335, there isn’t a whole lot of top vibration (due to the center block) so a top crack is less of an issue. On top of that, the crack in the top (or back) of a 335 is usually limited to the top ply of the plywood. It is most unusual for plywood to crack through more than one ply. So, even with a top crack, there isn’t a significant amount of disturbance to the vibration of the top. ES models made of plywood do this a lot. The top ply will crack from changes in humidity or temperature especially where the wood in the plies is different ply to ply. Different woods will expand and contract at different rates and when that happens, something has to give and it’s usually the top maple ply. Also, you can’t see the other plies so who would know?

There are cracks to the rim which can be trouble in a deep body guitar but rarely in a 335 or other thinline. They simply don’t happen very often. The crack in the headstock between the tuners (or just beneath them) is a pretty frequent issue. Sometimes it’s a separation in the “wings” of the headstock which isn’t a crack at all-it’s just a glue issue. If the crack is between the tuners, then it can be significant. get it glued up and it shouldn’t cause any further trouble. It can happen when tuners are changed and the new screws are slightly larger than the old ones. The headstock veneer on a 335 from the 50’s or 60’s is holly. It’s a hard, brittle wood that takes the black paint very well. It also cracks really easily. If you come across a guitar with a crack between the tuners, look to see if it goes all the way through the headstock. If it doesn’t, it’s not a big issue and won’t cause problems later. If the crack goes all the way through the headstock and you can see the same crack on the back of the headstock, then have your luthier look at it. That can be trouble but is easily fixed.

Lastly, we all love the thin top 335’s made in 58 (and a few in 59 and even 60) but they are prone to cracks around the area of the jack. A straight plug puts a lot of stress on the top due to the leverage caused by the length of the plug. Again, go back to your high school physics-you see it wasn’t a total waste of time. A 90 degree plug reduces that stress so a top crack around the jack is less likely. Too late if your 58 already has them (and more than half of them do) but as long as you’re careful (and use a 90 degree plug, it shouldn’t be a big issue. It is fixable. My luthier fixed my blonde 58 by gluing a round layer of wood inside the guitar around the jack hole. The area is much more stable now.

A crack doesn’t have to be a dealbreaker. One of my personal players has a “smile” crack at the headstock and was probably repaired 30 years ago and has never been an issue. A well executed repair can save you thousands. A cosmetic crack can also save you significant money even though it will never get worse or cause you trouble. So, is a guitar with no cracks of any kind more desirable than one with a small crack somewhere? No, the crack free guitar will always be more money and more desirable but if your heart says you must have a dot neck and your budget says block, maybe you should look at a dot with a crack somewhere. An experienced luthier will know whether it will be trouble down the road.

This type of crack is generally limited to thin top 58’s but is possible on later 3×5’s as well. This early 58 was repaired by essentially adding a layer to the plywood inside the guitar. it is totally stable now.

Verified by MonsterInsights